Temple Anshe Sholom Report

Rabbi Michael Weiss
Temple Anshe Sholom


As we approach Chanukah, our festival of lights in the darkest time of the year, I wanted to share wisdom from an unexpected place. In traditional Japanese art, kintsugi is a technique in which broken ceramic ware is repaired using lacquer mixed with gold dust. The result is something new and beautiful, accentuating the object’s unique history. The cracks are not hidden, but glint gold in the light.

In recent years, our community has felt so much brokenness, pain, and fear. Our response to brokenness, in the world and ourselves, is often to attempt to repair the harm. We rebuild, fill gaps, and plaster over our sadness. But our tradition warns us about this.
 
During Chanukah we tell the story of the Maccabees, who fought for religious freedom. ‘Chanukkah’ means dedication, emphasizing how the Maccabees rededicated the Temple in Jerusalem after Antiochus’ army desecrated it. They relit the menorah and rebuilt the altar, but as leaders of Judea, they forgot their purpose. They remade the Temple too well, forgetting they had fought for Jews’ rights to their uniqueness and sacred practices. The Maccabees became corrupt and self-indulgent conquerors, losing the hope that had led them to fight.
 
Our tradition offers a different model. The ark in that same Temple contained the tablets of the Ten Commandments along with the broken pieces of the first set, shattered by Moses when he saw the Israelites had made the Golden Calf. There was no attempt to repair them. The broken tablets were kept in our people’s holiest place as a reminder of our regret, the fear that led us to idolatry, and the brokenness we feel in ourselves and the world.
 
Even as we put everything back together, we need to see cracks. Our mistakes and pain are essential to who we are, reminding us where we’ve been and guiding us towards healing others. Kintsugi is not the only answer, as some things cannot be made beautiful with gold, but we need to remember the cracks, even as the trauma dulls. Let this season be one of healing and rededication to healing others’ wounds, never forgetting the scars, lest we return to the ways that caused us harm.